I'm participating in an intergenerational study with gay men right now. It is a writing group. We meet on Fridays for two hours and discuss/write about various things. Four juniors/seniors from DePaul University and then several older gay men. It is an absolutely fascinating experience, and I love using generational gaps as framework for larger theories/ideas.
Yesterday, we discussed the It Gets Better campaign. We were to write a short response to the campaign, as well as a response to the notion that It Gets Different. The writing was easy and I'll admit, I didn't think or reflect as much as I should've. But in the group's discussion, I did.
I realize I may sound like a cold, bitter fool here. I'm just processing thoughts. Putting things on the table. Creating discourse.
I don't understand why all the recent gay suicides are making national news. We had a National Spirit Day where people all across America--people identifying with each of the letters in our too-long acronym of LGBTQIA--wore purple to show their support of ending Anti-LGBTQ bullying. It's wonderful and beautiful that so many people showed their support.
There are hundreds of videos on YouTube for the It Gets Better. Everyone from Sarah Silverman to President Obama to the Broadway Cast of Wicked has created a video, explaining why and how it gets better. I'll admit, some of these videos are annoying. Some are mundane. Few are actually inspiring. But the fact that so many people are jumping on board is pretty cool, right?
But is it necessary? Is it helpful?
Gay students have been committing suicide for years--decades, even. So why now? Why are these cases making national news? Is it because America finally realizing something should be done about it? Is it because the media wants to stir something up? Or is it because our society missed this particular narrative? It used to be if a TV show, film, or play had a gay character, they died. Either suicide, AIDS, or murder. That's not the case anymore. We can finally be represented as happy, healthy, and living individuals.
Enter the media. Reintroducing the narrative that gays kill themselves. Yes, there is truth to this. LGBTQ students are four times more likely to commit suicide than heterosexual students. But sometimes, I blame the media more than I blame the bullies.
Kids are bullied for everything. You wear glasses? Bullied. You're overweight? Bullied. You wear the same outfit because you don't have money? Bullied. Freckles? Bullied. You're different in any capacity (never mind the reality that everybody is different)? Bullied.
So why is it that the gays seem to be the only ones driven to the point of suicide? Is it because they/we are bullied more? Possibly. Or is it because for years, the media and entertainment have hand-delivered an excuse to all gay youth? If we turned the spotlight away from gay suicide and worked to destroy this disgusting social narrative, would queer youth see suicide as an option?
Furthermore, I don't know if I agree with the It Gets Better campaign. I'd like to believe that the hardships, trials and bullies gay high school students are faced with disappear completely. But they don't. They change, yes. I'm not taunted in the hallways at DePaul University like I was at Des Moines Christian (ironic, I know). I'm still seen as second-class citizen by our government, though. I still cannot donate blood or serve openly in the military (not for long!). In many states, I can still lose my job or my housing just because I'm gay. Most states prevent me from marrying and adopting. I am still called "fag" and "homo" as I walk down the street.
I don't say this because I want to discourage the younger generation. I don't want that at all. But more important than "things getting better," I've developed thicker skin and a strong support system of family, friends, and boyfriend.
Things may not get
better . But they get
different.. And that difference is worth all the bullying, hardships and legal persecution thrown in our faces every day by the ignorant and asinine closed-minded fools living in America.